Your Local Insurance Team in Plain City, Ohio

Coverage. Care. Community.

Plain City’s roots run deep, and so does the pride its residents have in their homes, farms, and businesses. Whether you’re enjoying Der Dutchman, commuting into Columbus, or investing in local property, protecting what you’ve built is essential. That’s where we come in. Dwyer Insurance helps Plain City residents and business owners understand their options—from homeowners insurance that covers the unexpected, to commercial policies built for local growth. We know the local zoning quirks, the common risks, and how to keep your coverage in sync with your evolving life here in Union and Madison counties.

Plans that grow with families, farms, and futures in Plain City.

Plain City residents value honesty, family, and smart planning—and so do we. That’s why we take a custom approach to insurance, built on real conversations and local knowledge. We help you protect your farm, your home, your car, or your business with coverage that grows with you.

How The Sullivan Group Serves Plain City

When people in Plain City need insurance they can understand and trust, they come to The Sullivan Group. We’re proud to provide guidance, not jargon—and coverage that’s clear, flexible, and rooted in real life. With us, it’s not about upselling—it’s about protecting. Residents off W. Main Street. Commuters on U.S. 42. Local farm owners and their property. Business professionals near the square. Families focused on long-term security.

• 📞 Call Now for a Free Case Review – (817) 485-8888

Our history

Built with Care. Rebuilt with Pride.

The building at 63 N Main Street has seen more than policies pass through its doors—it's seen generations of commitment, community ties, and people-first values.